AI is handling client data and decisions in your agency, often without rules.
Agents use AI to compare quotes, draft client emails, summarise policies and handle claims paperwork. Most agencies haven't set rules for it yet. Meanwhile, insurers are being told to answer for every AI system they rely on, including the ones run by the people who sell their products.
The rules and the numbers.
Insurers must govern AI, including their partners'.
As of March 2025, 24 states had adopted the national insurance regulators' model bulletin, which expects insurers to keep a written AI program and to vet the third parties and AI systems they rely on. Expect questions to flow down to agencies.
Source: Quarles, March 2025
Staff use their own AI tools.
88% of employees who have AI at work also use personal AI tools for work.
Most agencies have no rules yet.
Research with agents across 13 states found most operate without formal AI governance or training.
Source: Cake & Arrow, reported by Risk & Insurance, June 2026
Real cases.
UnitedHealth's nH Predict, 2023 to now
Families of two Medicare Advantage members are suing UnitedHealth, alleging an AI tool overrode doctors and cut off care too early. A 2024 Senate investigation found UnitedHealth's denial rate for post-acute care more than doubled after it started using the tool. In March 2026 a federal court ordered UnitedHealth to hand over documents on how it was used. UnitedHealth's Optum disputes the claims.
When AI helps decide a claim, you'll be asked to show how, and who checked.
Where it goes wrong, and how we fix it.
Claims and client data pasted into AI tools.
Plus lists the tools approved for client and claims data, what must never go in, and trains your team on it. Starter checks the tools on your website and what their terms say about AI and data.
AI-drafted coverage advice that nobody checked.
A wrong summary of what a policy covers is an errors-and-omissions claim waiting to happen.
Plus adds a review step for anything AI drafts about cover before a client sees it, with training on what to check.
Decisions about people nobody can explain.
Plus requires a person to review, and be able to explain, any decision AI helps make about a client or a claim, and says what to record.
AI exclusions in your own cover nobody has read.
Your own professional and cyber cover may say something about AI. Has anyone read it?
Plus names someone to check your own insurance for AI exclusions every year, and puts it in your policy.
Questions from the insurers you place business with.
Pro gives you a ready answer pack for AI questionnaires, and a live badge that shows you're checked every week.
What it looks at.
Your website's text, the tools it loads and what they do with data, your privacy notice, and whether your chat says it's AI. Score, top three gaps and a plan recommendation in about 30 seconds.
See where your agency stands.
Your website, a few questions, and the three things to fix first.